William Contreras was named to the All-MLB Second Team on November 11, 2026, earning the Milwaukee Brewers their first All-MLB honoree since Freddy Peralta claimed the same distinction in 2025. The recognition lands Contreras among an elite group — just the fifth Brewers player in franchise history to appear on an All-MLB team — and caps a 2026 season that earned him league-wide recognition at one of the most demanding positions on the field.
William Contreras Named All-MLB Second Team Catcher for 2026
The All-MLB teams, voted on and announced after the conclusion of the regular season, recognize the best players at each position across the sport. For Contreras, the nod validates what he brought to Milwaukee in 2026 on both sides of the ball. It is the kind of hardware that reflects not just offensive production but the full picture of what a catcher contributes to a ballclub — game-calling, controlling the running game, and managing a pitching staff through a full season.
Franchise Context: Five All-MLB Honorees and Counting
With this recognition, the Brewers now have five All-MLB team selections in franchise history. Freddy Peralta's 2025 All-MLB Second Team nod was the most recent prior example, meaning the franchise has now put a player on an All-MLB team in back-to-back seasons. That kind of sustained individual excellence at the top level of the sport is worth noting for a mid-market franchise building through its roster.
Contreras arrived in Milwaukee as part of a core the organization has invested in, and this award signals that the investment has paid off in a measurable, league-recognized way. He is not the first Brewer to earn this distinction, but he is the latest — and the honor arrives with the franchise heading into an offseason with real decisions to make about its competitive window.
What This Means Going Into the 2027 Offseason
An All-MLB Second Team catcher is an asset worth building around. Contreras's presence anchors Milwaukee's battery at a position where finding elite-level talent is genuinely difficult. The recognition will also sharpen attention on his contract situation and what the front office does in the months ahead to put quality around him on the field at American Family Field.
For now, the honor stands on its own. William Contreras is an All-MLB Second Team catcher. The Brewers have produced back-to-back All-MLB honorees. That is not a small thing.